Place and first dwellings
Beers opens the chapter by placing Bolivar as the southeastern town in the Holland Purchase
. Beers (1879), p. 217 ↗
Before permanent settlement, Zephaniah Smith, a hunter from Unadilla in Otsego County, built a bark-roofed log house about sixteen feet square on lot 48 near the later site of Richburgh — described as the first dwelling in the town — and spent winters hunting there, last visiting in the winter of 1818–19. Many later pioneers from Otsego County first heard of the place through him. Beers (1879), p. 217 ↗
“A blanket hung over the opening did service as a door.” Beers (1879), p. 217 ↗
First permanent settlers
Timothy Cowles, a Vermont native coming from Otsego County, arrived December 8, 1819, and settled on lot 61 — called the first permanent settler. Jonathan Hitchcock took up part of lot 48 in the spring of 1819, renovated Smith's hut, and brought his wife and four children back on February 15, 1820. Beers (1879), p. 217 ↗
Christopher Tyler moved into the same Smith house that winter; Asa and Austin Cowles followed into Bolivar in February 1820. Eli Lesuer settled on lot 62 in the autumn of 1821; Samuel Davie bought part of lot 62 in March 1823 and brought what Beers calls the first team of horses to that section. Beers (1879), p. 217 ↗
Pioneer life
When settlement began, the nearest grist-mills were at Friendship and Ceres; Olean and Cuba were the most convenient markets. Settlers hauled grists on a sled with two yokes of oxen — a two- or three-day trip. Beers (1879), p. 218 ↗
“The only article that commanded money was black salts, which nearly all of the settlers made.” Beers (1879), p. 218 ↗
Beers also recounts how Samuel Frost, out picking chestnuts with his sons one Sunday afternoon in the autumn of 1825, became lost in the woods and was found days later lying beside a log, weak and nearly insensible. Beers (1879), p. 218 ↗ Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
Firsts in town
- First white child born: Almond W. Cowles, 1820. Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
- First religious services: Methodists in Jonathan Hitchcock's barn, 1820, led by Austin Cowles; first church of that denomination organized in 1828. Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
- First school-house: a log building on the northeast corner of lot 55 in 1820; Rachel Gilbert taught the first (summer) school. Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
- First saw-mill: Little Genesee Creek, lot 55, 1822 (Tyler and the Cowleses, with Luther Austin as millwright). First framed house: Luther Austin, lot 55. First death: a child of Luther Austin, 1823. First grist-mill: Asa Cowles at the village, 1824. First marriage: Daniel Kellogg and Sophia Hitchcock, 1825. Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
- First store at Bolivar village: Hollis B. Newton with Asa Cowles, 1825; first public house there opened by Newton in 1831. Beers (1879), p. 219 ↗
Town organized
The town was formed from Friendship on February 15, 1825; a portion was taken off to help form Wirt on April 12, 1838. The first town meeting was March 1, 1825, at H. B. Newton's tavern in Bolivar village. Beers (1879), p. 220 ↗
“Voted that the town shall pay five dollars to any inhabitant who shall kill a grown wolf or panther in said town, and half that sum for whelps.” Beers (1879), p. 220 ↗
Beers describes Bolivar village (northwest part of the town, on Little Genesee Creek) as having a flouring mill, tannery, shops, hotel, several stores, an attorney and two physicians, and a population of about two hundred. Beers (1879), p. 220 ↗
Church and population (as of Beers)
The Bolivar Methodist Episcopal Church, organized in 1828, built its house of worship in 1843 at a cost of $1,900 on a lot donated by Nelson Hoyt; Beers gives the membership as about one hundred and twenty. Beers (1879), p. 221 ↗
Population figures Beers records include 499 in 1830, 752 in 1835, then 408 in 1840 after the 1838 split with Wirt, rising again to 1,002 in 1875. Beers (1879), p. 221 ↗