The hunter's hut
Before there was a Bolivar, there was Zephaniah Smith, a hunter from Unadilla who spent several winters here. Child's 1875 gazetteer says his log hut was the first human habitation in town, and early settlers lived in it until they built their own. Timothy Cowles made the first permanent settlement on Dec. 8, 1819. The first log cabin on the future village site went up around 1820.
A quiet farm town
Bolivar was split from Friendship in 1825. In 1870 the town had 959 people, and the village had only about 180. To the south, the hamlet now called South Bolivar was known as Honeoye Corners.
The gusher
Oil men had been testing the county for years. In 1879 O. P. Taylor's 'Triangle No. 1' near Wellsville became the county's first flowing well. Then on April 28, 1881, the Richburg gusher came in on the Reading farm, lot 33 in Wirt, just over Bolivar's line. It made 80 barrels on its first day. In Minard's words, it 'made oil towns of Richburg and Bolivar.' The Campbell well and others in Bolivar soon followed, and hundreds of holes were drilled across Alma, Bolivar, Wirt and Scio.
Boom days
Minard describes oil scouts sneaking around wells at midnight, while guards fired rifles into the dark to keep them away. Bolivar village was incorporated in 1882. Over in Richburg, a young L. Frank Baum, who later wrote The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, managed Baum's Opera House from 1881 until it burned in March 1882. Wikipedia reports a local claim that the Bolivar–Richburg area was briefly the wealthiest place per capita in the United States. We haven't seen proof of that yet, so treat it as local legend.
A second wind
The first boom had faded by the early 1900s. Starting around 1920, secondary recovery, which forces leftover oil out of the sands, brought the field back. By the early 1930s the village had a new school, paved streets and a busy Main Street. Bolivar took the nickname 'Land of the Deer and the Derrick.'
From the 1879 county history
- Bolivar is described as the southeastern town of the Holland Purchase.
- Zephaniah Smith, a hunter from Unadilla, Otsego County, built the first dwelling in the town: a log house about sixteen feet square with a bark roof, on lot 48 near the site of Richburgh. Many later pioneers came from Otsego County because of him.
- The first permanent settler was Timothy Cowles, a Vermont native, who arrived from Otsego County on December 8, 1819, and located on lot 61.
- Jonathan Hitchcock took up part of lot 48 in the spring of 1819, renovated Smith's hut, and brought in his wife and four children on February 15, 1820.
- The town was formed from Friendship on February 15, 1825; part was taken off for Wirt on April 12, 1838. The first town meeting was March 1, 1825, at H. B. Newton's tavern.
- The first school-house (log, lot 55) and Methodist services in Hitchcock's barn both date to 1820; the Methodist church was organized in 1828 and built its meetinghouse in 1843.
“A blanket hung over the opening did service as a door.”
“The only article that commanded money was black salts, which nearly all of the settlers made.”
Then & now
Pump jacks still nod in the hills. The Bolivar Free Library has been on the National Register since 2003, and Bolivar and Richburg have shared a school district since 1994.