Every town, board, game and gathering in Allegany County, with a link to the source.
Twenty-nine towns, each with its own beginning: a hunter's hut, a pioneer's two cents, an Irish immigrant's farm, a general's debt. Here are their stories, drawn from 19th-century histories we actually read.
The county's history starts with the Seneca, who lived along the Genesee and harvested pigeons in the woods near today's Wellsville. After the Revolution, land companies and speculators carved the country into tracts, and settlers came in on Indian paths from Pennsylvania, New England and eastern New York.
Angelica, formed in 1805, is the oldest town, created before the county itself. Philip Church laid it out as a little Paris, and it was the county seat until Belmont took over in 1859. Over the next fifty years the towns split again and again; Ward, from 1856, is one of the youngest.
Pine and hemlock came first, then cheese, the canal and the Erie Railroad. In 1879 and 1881 oil came in at Triangle City and Richburg, turning quiet towns like Bolivar into boom towns.
Formed from Angelica on March 11, 1808
Short, page-cited readings of individual town chapters in F. W. Beers & Co., Illustrated History of Allegany County, N.Y. (1879). Public domain; each fact links to the printed page in a public scan.
Alfred voted to pay four dollars for every wolf killed, then spent the next century becoming a college town. Seventh Day Baptist families set the tone early, and by 1875 the town hadn't granted a liquor license in more than thirty years.
In 1875 Allen had no village, no hotel, no store, no minister, no doctor and no lawyer. What it did have was the county's first-born Wilson and a whole lot of quiet hills.
Alma has the county's high ground, a pine forest that was cut nearly bare by 1875, and an oil boom town called Allentown that a narrow-gauge railroad served for about a dozen years.
Settlers from Pennsylvania came in 1796. A log schoolhouse with a bark roof opened in 1802. And it's pronounced like 'Alma,' not like the nut.
When the Erie Railroad reached Belvidere in 1851, Judge Philip Church gave the station a flag showing an engine, an Indian and a deer, with a verse ending 'Look up to Heaven and see how small you are!' Amity also holds the county seat.
Pine built Andover. By 1875 the village had about 850 people, a tannery and its own newspaper, and the town had produced a World Series record-setter.
The county's oldest town was laid out like a little Paris: a circle at the center, streets radiating out like a star, and churches set around the green. It was named for a famous mother.
It started out as 'Orrinsburgh' and became Belfast a year later, when settlers from northern Ireland put their stamp on it. The Genesee Valley Canal and a seminary came later.
Birdsall is named for a judge. For 65 years it sat on a railroad main line, until federal regulators let the line go in 1947.
A lone hunter's log hut was the first roof in Bolivar. Sixty years later the derricks came, and Bolivar and Richburg became oil towns almost overnight. Some say the area was briefly the richest per person in the country.
No, Burns wasn't named for a fire. It was named for the Scottish poet Robert Burns. Its pioneers walked in on an Indian path, and one of them could knit a whole pair of stockings on the walk to Canaseraga and back.
The name is said to mean 'where the heavens rest upon the earth.' A Seneca council house stood here, and so did the canal, the Underground Railroad, and a village that's now under a lake.
Joseph Maxson was 18 when he arrived with two cents in his pocket. He traded his new shoes for an axe and spent eight months alone in the woods sleeping on basswood bark.
In 1822 the Slayton brothers cut their own road from Cuba so they could get to their land. Sawmills ran here for decades after.
A French missionary wrote about an oil spring here in 1627, often called the first recorded mention of oil in North America. Later the town dammed a creek to feed a canal, and for a century it set the price of cheese.
People say it was once called 'Bloody Corners' for its weekend brawls, until the better-behaved residents went the other way and named it Friendship.
Genesee has a 'Rock City' of giant white-pebble boulders laid out like streets. In 1875 it claimed that no resident had ever been sent to state prison.
Granger was formed as 'West Grove' and renamed a year later for the Postmaster General. In 1875 it had no hotel at all, and Child called its people 'a moral people.'
Grove's first house stood at the end of a road its builder cut himself from Nunda. Its first school met in that same cabin. And the 'Ossian Giant,' a 7-foot-6 traveling showman, chose it as home.
Roger Mills paid a guide one dollar to walk Wiscoy Creek with him looking for a mill site. The creek drops about seventy feet at Wiscoy, and Child called it the best water power in the county.
Six distilleries, a foundry making farm tools, and potatoes by the thousands of bushels. Nobody knows why the town is called Independence.
The town was first named for a militia general, Haight, until his demands wore people out and they renamed it. Two creeks here start so close together that in a flood fish cross from one to the other, even though one flows to the Gulf of Mexico and the other to the St. Lawrence.
When the dam went in on Caneadea Creek in 1927, two hamlets, East Rushford and Kelloggville, ended up under what is now Rushford Lake.
A Revolutionary War minuteman named Knight settled here in 1805, and Scio once took in the land that became Wellsville. Out at 'Triangle City,' oil showed up in 1879.
Ward is one of the county's youngest towns, made from pieces of Alfred and Amity. In the Civil War it sent 81 soldiers.
Wellsville is named for the one man who skipped the naming meeting. For two years in the 1870s it was legally called 'Genesee.' Then oil, a refinery and a train line built it into a busy hub.
In West Almond, Angelica, Philips, Karr Valley and Black creeks all start at least partly inside the town, and the West Almond churches are on the National Register.
West of the river, Willing families peeled hemlock bark in summer for the Wellsville tanneries and hauled logs in winter. A tornado tore through in 1884.
On Caleb Wilcox's farm in 1875, rain off one side of the roof flowed to the Mississippi and rain off the other side went to the St. Lawrence. Richburg's gusher made this an oil town.
Our town sketches draw from these free, public collections. Know of a scrapbook, photo or clipping? Email news@alleganyalmanac.com.