Settled by an Irish immigrant
James Wilson came over from Ireland in 1804 and settled in what became Allen around 1806. His son, Col. William Wilson, born Jan. 30, 1810, was probably the first child born in town, according to Child's gazetteer. The town was split off from Angelica in 1823, and in 1829 it gained more land from Birdsall.
A town without a village
Child's 1875 sketch is blunt about it: Allen had no village, hotel, store, minister, doctor or lawyer. Today's place names include Allen Center, Aristotle, Polish Mountain and Wigwam Creek, and each of them probably has a story we haven't found yet.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Allen chapter selection →
- James Wilson, a native of Ireland who came to America in 1804 and lived for a time at Geneva and Angelica, is credited as the first settler within Allen, locating on Baker's Creek in 1806.
- The book says a few settlements were made soon after 1800, but the town was not generally settled until after 1820.
- Allen was formed from Angelica on January 31, 1823, and the first town meeting was held April 1, 1823. James Wilson was chosen supervisor.
- The first school was taught near the south line of the town in 1820, and the first religious services were held by Rev. Robert Hubbard, a Presbyterian, in 1821.
- Dairying was the chief pursuit of the inhabitants.
- The book says Allen had no hotels or stores at the time of writing.
“With ax and gun, with sturdy arms and iron will, the grand work of carving out the civilization of to-day was begun.”
“The inhabitants are essentially an agricultural community and number among them neither a doctor, lawyer, or preacher”

Then & now
Allen Center and Aristotle are still small crossroads on Basswood Hill Road.