Allegany County, New YorkWed, Nov 18 · Late Autumn · Thanksgiving
Sun & SeasonLate Autumn · ThanksgivingBare maples, woodsmoke, deer season, and a full table.
✦ Est. 2026 · Bolivar, N.Y. ✦

The Allegany AlmanacThe Allegany Almanac

— Being a Daily Record of the 29 Towns & 10 Villages —
ContentsMeetings · Schools · SportsEvents · Safety · Records

Every town, board, game and gathering in Allegany County, with a link to the source.

← Town of Alma · All town histories

History of Alma

Alma has the county's high ground, a pine forest that was cut nearly bare by 1875, and an oil boom town called Allentown that a narrow-gauge railroad served for about a dozen years.

Pine and sawmills

Warren Hough arrived from Quebec in 1833. For the next forty years Alma was lumber country. By 1875 the pine was 'nearly exhausted,' Child wrote. Pikeville took its name from a Mr. Pike's sawmills and faded after they burned. Shongo was once called Honeoye.

Oil

In January 1881 the McBride well came in on lot 18 in Alma with sixty feet of good oil sand, and nearby land sold almost immediately for $100 to $200 an acre (Minard). Allentown grew into a rough-and-ready oil town. From 1881 to 1893 the three-foot narrow-gauge Bradford, Eldred & Cuba Railroad ran through, until the boom faded and the line was abandoned.

From the 1879 county history

Read the page-cited Alma chapter selection →

Summarized from F. W. Beers, Illustrated History of Allegany County, N.Y. (1879), town chapter pp. 155–158. The summaries are in our words. Quoted text keeps the book's 1879 wording and outlook, which we reproduce as a historical source, not as our view. About this source.

  • The first settler in Alma was Warren Hough, from Quebec, Canada, who located in the south part of the town. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 155)
  • Azor Hurlbutt, a Connecticut native born January 27, 1793, came to Alma in 1834, settled on lot 26 and served as justice of the peace for about thirty years. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 155)
  • Lumbering had been the leading business, but by 1879 the pine was nearly gone and farming was gaining ground along the creeks. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 157)
  • Near the center of town the book describes a rough tract of sandstone rock of one to two hundred acres, covered with moss and huge sandstone blocks. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 157)
“A great portion of the town is yet covered by forests, though the supply of pine is almost exhausted, and lumbering has been the leading business interest” — Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 157

Then & now

Allentown is still on the map along Route 417. Bits of the old narrow-gauge railbed can be spotted near West Clarksville.

Photos

Photo coming soonAn old photo of the main corners
Photo coming soonA landmark that still stands

Have an old photo of Alma? Send it to news@alleganyalmanac.com.