Lumber town
For decades pine lumber was Andover's main business, according to Child. By 1875 the village had about 850 residents, a tannery and the Andover Advertiser, founded in 1868. Out west of the village, Elm Valley was then called Shoemakers Corners.
Born here
Patsy Dougherty, the first player to hit two home runs in a single World Series game, was born in Andover. So was Thomas Allen, who later became Wisconsin's secretary of state.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Andover chapter selection →
- Andover was formed from Independence in January 1824, and part of Wellsville was added on November 22, 1855.
- The first settlement was made in 1796 at Elm Valley by Stephen Cole, from Tioga County, Pa. James Dyke, from Tioga Point, settled nearby so early that the book says it is uncertain which man came first.
- Thaddeus Baker, Sr., of Poultney, Vt., arrived in 1807 and bought four hundred acres that took in part of the future village site. He had earlier surveyed for the Pulteney heirs and picked the land while doing so.
- Robert R. Boyd had to cut a road from Elm Valley to his lot, and he lived in the woods under blankets until he could build a log house.
“Daniel Cole, his son, who was born February 18th, 1797, was the first white child born in Allegany county.”

Then & now
Dyke Creek, named for pioneer Nathaniel Dyke, still runs through town toward Wellsville.