Allegany County, New YorkWed, Nov 18 · Late Autumn · Thanksgiving
Sun & SeasonLate Autumn · ThanksgivingBare maples, woodsmoke, deer season, and a full table.
✦ Est. 2026 · Bolivar, N.Y. ✦

The Allegany AlmanacThe Allegany Almanac

— Being a Daily Record of the 29 Towns & 10 Villages —
ContentsMeetings · Schools · SportsEvents · Safety · Records

Every town, board, game and gathering in Allegany County, with a link to the source.

← Town of Birdsall · All town histories

History of Birdsall

Birdsall is named for a judge. For 65 years it sat on a railroad main line, until federal regulators let the line go in 1947.

This is a short sketch. We're still digging into old newspapers and talking with town historians, and the full story is coming soon.

Settlers and a school

Josiah Whitman settled here in 1816, and Hannah Scott taught the first school in 1822. The town is named for John Birdsall, circuit judge of the Eighth District in 1828–29.

On the line, then off it

From 1882 until April 1, 1947, Birdsall was on the main line of the Pittsburg, Shawmut & Northern and the railroads before it. The line was abandoned in 1947.

From the 1879 county history

Read the page-cited Birdsall chapter selection →

Summarized from F. W. Beers, Illustrated History of Allegany County, N.Y. (1879), town chapter pp. 214–216. The summaries are in our words. Quoted text keeps the book's 1879 wording and outlook, which we reproduce as a historical source, not as our view. About this source.

  • Birdsall was named in honor of Judge John Birdsall, circuit judge of the eighth judicial district, and was organized from Allen and Almond by an act of May 4, 1829. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 214)
  • The first settlement was made in 1816 by Josiah Whitman, on lot number 24. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 214)
  • The first saw-mill was built by William Lord on Black Creek in 1823 or 1824. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 214)
  • The first town meeting was held March 2, 1830, at the house of James Matthews; Andrew C. Hull was chosen supervisor. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 215)
  • The Allegany Chemical Works, on the headwaters of the Canisteo River, was built in 1875 and made alcohol, acetate of lime and charcoal, using about two thousand cords of hardwood a year. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 215)
  • The book notes there were no villages in Birdsall, only the hamlets of Birdsall and Birdsall Center. (Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 215)
“The business is carried on day and night, and at times as many as fifty men are employed” — Beers, History of Allegany County (1879), p. 215

Then & now

Keaney Swamp, a large bog near the north line, is one of the town's landmarks.

Photos

Photo coming soonAn old photo of the main corners
Photo coming soonA landmark that still stands

Have an old photo of Birdsall? Send it to news@alleganyalmanac.com.