Two cents and an axe
Joseph Maxson left Otsego County and reached Pike in April 1808. At Pike he traded his new shoes for an axe and pushed into the woods, where he built a shanty and peeled basswood bark for a floor and a blanket. Snow fell six inches deep soon after he settled in. The land office records five acres cleared by July 22, 1808 (from an 1869 Allegany County Advocate article quoted by Child).
Hotels for the westward crowd
Early town records count six hotels and only forty-eight voters. That makes sense once you know the road carried a steady stream of families heading west. In 1873 the Lamberson cheese factory took in more than 2.7 million pounds of milk.
Welsh, Amish and The Aldrich Family
Welsh families settled the southwest part of town in the 1840s. More recently, Amish farmers have bought land here. Playwright Clifford Goldsmith set The Aldrich Family in a fictional town modeled on Centerville.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Centerville chapter selection →
- Centerville (spelled Centreville in the book) was formed from Pike, Wyoming County, on January 15, 1819. Jesse Bullock was the first supervisor and Alfred Forbes the first town clerk.
- To serve voters spread across the town, early elections ran over two or three days at different houses. The 1819 election opened at Jesse Bullock's house on April 27, moved to Strong Warner's on the 28th, and to Russell Trall's on the 29th.
“In the early days, for the better accommodation of the scattered voters, elections were held two or three successive days in different parts of the town.”

Then & now
The Centerville Town Hall has been on the National Register since 2009, and Amish buggies are a common sight on the roads.