Church Tract
Grove started out as part of Nunda, in Livingston County. It was formed in 1827 under the name 'Church Tract,' after the Church family land. Our sources disagree on when it became Grove: Child says 1828, and Wikipedia says April 16, 1838. One guess, not confirmed, is that the name comes from its many trees. In 1838 it gave up its western half to form West Grove, which is now Granger.
John White's cabin
Settlement began in May 1818. John White came from Herkimer County with an ox team and his family, cutting his own road from Nunda. His log house was the first in town. By 1820 it was also the schoolhouse (Emily Page taught there) and the church, where Methodists met under Rev. Cyrus Story. The first birth was Laura Bailey's, on Christmas Day 1821. The first wedding, in 1822, was Elijah White and Lucy Dana's.
Brewers Corners
Jonathan Parsons was the first to settle at what became Brewers Corners, in 1822. Daniel G. Brewer, who gave it his name, came in May 1823. Brewer said the first wheat grown in town yielded forty-three bushels an acre. During the lumber years the Corners was busy. By 1875 only four or five families were left, the kind of fade-away hamlet that's easy to miss on today's map.
Railroads and a valley
By 1875 two railroads crossed the town: the Erie's Buffalo branch and the Rochester, Nunda & Pennsylvania, which looped into Burns and came back on a sharp curve. Swainsville, now Swain, sat in what Child called a 'picturesque valley' with hills rising 400 to 600 feet. It had about 75 people. The Carter cheese factory turned 163,207 pounds of milk into cheese in the 1873 season.
The Ossian Giant
Frederick Decker, the 'Ossian Giant,' stood 7 feet 6 inches and weighed 385 pounds. He was born in Geneseo in 1836, toured the country showing himself, then settled in Grove, where he died and was buried in 1886.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Grove chapter selection →
- Grove was formed from the old town of Nunda as "Church Tract" on March 8, 1827, and renamed Grove the next year. It lost territory on April 18, 1838, when Granger was created.
- The first settlement was made in May 1818 by John White, from Herkimer County, on lot 35. He cut a road ahead of his ox team from Nunda, and his log cabin was the first house in the town.
- Alexander Bailey, a Vermont native, arrived in March 1818, two months before White, but did not settle in the town until the spring of 1819.
“His log cabin was the first civilized habitation erected in the town.”

Then & now
Swain Ski Resort, described on Wikipedia as the oldest operating ski resort in the state, now gives Swain its winter crowds. Brewers Corners is still a crossroads at Johnson Hill and Ridge roads.