White's village
Samuel S. White settled in 1819, built the first hotel, kept a store, and gave Whitesville its name. Child counted six distilleries in the town's history and a foundry making farm tools after 1850. Historians have never found a reason for the name Independence.
Rails, flood, decline
From 1896 the New York & Pennsylvania Railway ran through Whitesville. The July 1935 floods wrecked the line, it was abandoned in 1936, and Whitesville's economy took a long-term hit.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Independence chapter selection →
- Independence was formed from Alfred on March 16, 1821. Andover was set off on January 28, 1824, and part of Willing later.
- The first town meeting was held at Luther Strong's house in April 1821, and Strong was elected the first supervisor. Joseph Clark was the first town clerk.


Then & now
Whitesville is still the town's center on Route 248.