Cheese and an academy
Enos (or Eneas) Gary came from Vermont in 1808 and built the first framed barn. Child says it was still standing in 1875. By then Rushford made as much cheese as any town in the county, some of it pineapple cheese.
The drowned hamlets
The 1927 dam created Rushford Lake and flooded East Rushford and Kelloggville. In 1875 East Rushford had had a tannery, a gristmill and about 29 houses. Rushford also produced a governor, Frank W. Higgins, and Richard Henry Pratt, who founded the Carlisle Indian Industrial School.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Rushford chapter selection →
- According to the Holland Land Company's books, the first men to take articles for land in Rushford (township 5, range 2) were Charles Swift, Eneas Garey, Othniel Perry, William Vaughan, Andre Bennett and Joshua Wilson, in 1808.
- Settlement began near the center of the town, with Garey as the first settler.
- Beers describes Abraham J. Lyon as a lawyer from Sullivan, Madison County, who served for several years as justice of the peace and took a leading part in town politics.
“It will be observed that settlement begun near the center of the town”



Then & now
On low-water days, people still talk about what lies under Rushford Lake.