Knight's creek
Joseph Knight, a minuteman in the Revolution, came from Oneida County in 1805, and Knights Creek is named for him. Until 1857 Scio included what is now Wellsville.
Triangle City
On June 12, 1879, O. P. Taylor's Triangle No. 1 on lot 4 in Scio became the county's first flowing well. Minard quotes an Elmira paper reporting four lager-beer stands and several hundred people within days. The camp was called Triangle City until 1881, when it needed a post office and another town already had the Triangle name, so it became Petrolia.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Scio chapter selection →
- Scio was formed from Angelica on January 31, 1823, and later gave up territory to Amity, Willing and Wellsville.
- The pioneer settler was Joseph Knight, a Worcester County, Mass., native who came in 1805. The path he cut in from the Belmont direction was the first road of any kind in the town.
- At first the Knights had to go to Elm Valley for supplies. In their second year they planted corn with a hoe on new, unplowed land and harvested three hundred bushels.
“To erect a log house, the pioneer's castle, was the first work Mr. Knight's hands found to do”




Then & now
Petrolia is still on County Road 18. Marine Cpl. Jason Dunham, a Medal of Honor recipient, was born in Scio.