A poet's name
Burns was split off from Ossian, then part of Livingston County, in 1826. Many people assume the name comes from a fire in Canaseraga, but it honors Robert Burns, the Scottish poet.
The first families
Moses and Jeremiah Gregory, John Gaddis and Samuel Rodman settled in 1805. Child passes along a story that Mrs. Rodman used to walk to Canaseraga to visit, knitting a pair of stockings along the way. William Carroll, a Revolutionary War soldier who later went to sea, came in 1806 from southwestern Pennsylvania with his wife, five sons and three daughters. His son John didn't own a pair of shoes until he was eight and grew up to be a well-known hunter who kept the neighbors in game.
Ox carts and an Indian path
Thomas Boylan was the first settler at Canaseraga. In the spring of 1806 he and his son James came from Bluff Point on Crooked Lake (Keuka) with supplies on their backs. They cleared six acres, went home for the harvest, and came back with an ox cart. At Dansville the road ran out and there was only an Indian path, so they loaded everything onto the oxen. One ox was later found dead, and Boylan had to walk back for another.
Whitney Valley becomes Canaseraga
Canaseraga started as Whitney Valley. Until about 1840 the hamlet of Burns (once DeWittsville) was the bigger place. By 1875 Canaseraga had about 800 people and its own paper, the Canaseraga Times, first printed Nov. 27, 1873. The village was incorporated in 1892. In 1870 the town had 1,340 people.
From the 1879 county history
Read the page-cited Burns chapter selection →
- Burns was named in honor of the Scottish poet Robert Burns and was originally part of the Morris Reserve.
- The first settlement was made on Canaseraga Creek in 1805 by Moses and Jeremiah Gregory, Samuel Rodman and John Gaddis.
- Samuel Boylan took up one hundred sixty acres where the village of Canaseraga later stood. Beyond Dansville he had to leave his cart and load everything onto his oxen, because only an Indian path led on.
“Mrs. Samuel Rodman is said to have been an uncommonly rapid knitter.”
Then & now
The Canaseraga Four Corners Historic District has been on the National Register since 2002. The village still has a school, pre-K through 12, and a fall harvest festival.